Dharma Volkswagen van: $47,500
Daniel Faraday's journal with Jughead notes and reminder about Desmond Hume being his Constant: $27,500
The Frozen Donkey Wheel: $25,000
Hurley's Camaro: $24,000
A copy of the pilot script, signed by J.J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof: $15,000
The fail-safe key turned by Desmond Hume: $11,000
The controversial squirrel baby could have been yours' for a mere $2,750. (Profiles in History)
Jack's bloody outfit from the final scene: $10,000
Large piece of the fuselage: $9,000
Charlie Pace's Drive Shaft ring: $9,000
John Locke's suicide letter to Jack: $9,000
Kate's toy airplane: $6,500
Benjamin Linus's fake money and passports: $5,000
Hurley's notebook with his rewrite of the "Empire Strikes Back": $4,250
Sawyer's copy of "Watership Down": $3,300
Claire's Squirrel Baby: $2,750 (perhaps it didn't go for more due to the Squirrel Baby controversy?)
Rousseau's music box: $1,800
The fact that you now can't afford your monthly mortgage payments because you spent so much money on "Lost" auction stuff?: Priceless.